The Hidden Gem Cafe (now The Stuffed American) Menu

Welcome to The Hidden Gem Cafe, now rebranded as The Stuffed American, located on the lower level of 275 Broadhollow Rd in Melville, NY. This cozy café has built a reputation for its delectable menu, perfect for breakfast and lunch lovers alike.

• Breakfast Highlights: The New Yorker, featuring two eggs and cheese on a roll for just $4.99, is ideal for a quick but satisfying start to your day. If you’re feeling indulgent, the Hardcore—with sausage, hash browns, and cheddar on Texas toast at $7.99—will delight your taste buds.
• Sandwiches and Wraps: Don’t miss the Truffle Shuffle, loaded with crispy chicken and truffle burrata, or the inventive Honey Wrap, featuring turkey and honey mustard—a crowd-pleaser at $10.99.
• Appetizers: The truffle parmesan fries and jalapeno poppers provide the perfect accompaniment to any meal.

With a focus on fresh ingredients and friendly service, The Stuffed American truly lives up to its name—a culinary treasure in Melville.

BREAKFAST

• THE NEW YORKER

  2 EGGS WITH CHOICE OF CHEESE ON A ROLL

  US$4.99

• THE HARDCORE

  2 EGGS, SAUSAGE, HASH BROWN, CHEDDAR ON TEXAS TOAST

  US$7.99

• BAGEL OR ROLL

  WITH CREAM CHEESE OR BUTTER

  US$2.50

• FRENCH TOAST

  CINNAMON DUSTED TEXAS TOAST.

  US$7.99

• BREAKFAST PLATTER

  2 EGGS, BUTTERED TOAST, AND HOME FRIES

  US$7.99

• PESTO EGG WRAP

  3 EGGS, FRESH MOZZARELLA, PESTO

  US$6.99

SALADS / MAKE IT A WRAP

• ITALIAN SALAD

  FRESH SPINACH, FRESH MOZZARELLA, TOMATOES, OLIVES, RED PEPPER, BALSAMIC GLAZE AND OLIVE OIL

  US$8.99

• COBB

  GRILLED CHICKEN, ROMAINE, TOMATO, AVOCADO, BACON, HARD BOILED EGG, GORGONZOLA

  US$12.99

• IT'S ALL GREEK TO ME

  LETTUCE, TOMATO, CUCUMBER, ONIONS, FETA, OLIVES, CHICK PEAS, GREEK DRESSING

  US$8.99

• SPICY DEAL

  SPICY BUFFALO FRIED CHICKEN, LETTUCE, CARROTS, CELERY, CHEDDAR, MONTEREY JACK, BANANA PEPPERS, TORTILLA CHIPS, CREAMY BUFFALO RANCH

  US$12.99

• CHOPPED

  ROMAINE, TOMATO, CUCUMBER, RED ONIONS, CELERY, SHREDDED CARROTS

  US$7.99

• CAESAR

  ROMAINE, CROUTONS, PARMESAN, CAESAR DRESSING

  US$7.99

• AVOCADO TOAST

  TRUFFLE BURRATA $8.49, TOMATO, FRESH MOZZARELLA, BALSAMIC GLAZE $7.99

• OMELETTE-CREATE YOUR OWN

  BASE PRICE

  US$6.99

• HUNGRYMAN HERO

  3 EGGS, BACON, SAUSAGE, CHEESE, TATER TOTS ON A HERO

  US$9.99

• BOUJEE SALAD

  MIXED GREENS, BEETS, WALNUTS, GORGONZOLA, MANDARIN ORANGE, BALSAMIC VINAIGRETTE

  US$9.99

• NACHO AVERAGE SALAD

  ROMAINE, CORN, BEANS, TOMATOES, TORTILLA CHIPS, RED ONION, CHEDDAR, AVOCADO, CHIPOTLE DRESSING

  US$9.99

• CREATE YOUR OWN SALAD

  BASE PRICE

  US$7.99

SANDWICHES / WRAPS / MELTS

• TRUFFLE SHUFFLE

  CRISPY CHICKEN, TRUFFLE BURRATA, ARUGULA, BALSAMIC GLAZE, ROASTED PEPPERS, ON ROLL

  US$11.99

• HONEY WRAP

  TURKEY, MUENSTER, SPINACH, TOMATO, HONEY MUSTARD IN A WRAP

  US$10.99

• BLAT

  BACON, LETTUCE, AVOCADO, TOMATO, & GARLIC AIOLI ON WHITE TOAST

  US$10.99

• CHIPOTLE MELT

  GRILLED CHICKEN, PEPPER JACK, TOMATO, AVOCADO, MIXED GREENS, CHIPOTLE, ON WHEAT BREAD

  US$11.99

• CHICKEN PESTO IS THE BESTO

  GRILLED CHICKEN, MOZZARELLA, ROASTED RED PEPPER, SPINACH, PESTO, ON MULTIGRAIN ROLL

  US$11.99

• MEGA GRILLED CHEESE

  AMERICAN, BACON AND TOMATO

  US$7.99

• KICKED UP GRILLED CHEESE

  MOZZARELLA, PROVOLONE, PEPPERONI, HOT HONEY

  US$7.99

• GRILLED CHEESE

  US$5.99

• THE SWEET CAJUN

  GRILLED CHICKEN, CHEDDAR, SWEET CAJUN PICKLES, LETTUCE, RANCH ON A ROLL

  US$11.99

• ORCHARD TURKEY

  HONEY TURKEY, BRIE, MIXED GREENS, SLICED APPLE, FIG JAM ON CIABATTA

  US$11.99

• WHAT'S YOUR BEEF?

  ROAST BEEF, SWISS, LETTUCE, TOMATO, ONION, CREAMY HORSERADISH, IN A WRAP

  US$11.99

• THE BIG BEEF

  ROAST BEEF, BACON, SWISS, COLE SLAW, RUSSIAN, ON A HERO

  US$11.99

• TWISTED SISTER

  FRIED CHICKEN, BACON, ARUGULA, CARAMELIZED ONIONS, MUENSTER, AVOCADO, GARLIC AIOLI, ON TEXAS TOAST

  US$11.99

• TURKEY BLT

  TURKEY, BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO, MAYO, ON A MULTIGRAIN ROLL

  US$11.99

• CAPRESE

  TOMATO, MOZZARELLA, SPINACH, RED PEPPER, PESTO, BALSAMIC GLAZE, ON A CIABATTA PANINI

  US$10.99

• CHICKEN CLASSIC

  FRIED CHICKEN, AMERICAN, BACON, LETTUCE, TOMATO, RUSSIAN, ON A ROLL

  US$11.99

• ITALIAN STALLION

  SALAMI, HAM, PEPPERONI, LETTUCE, BANANA PEPPERS, RED ONION, OLIVE OIL, PROVOLONE ON A HERO

  US$11.99

• HUMMUS WRAP

  GRILLED CHICKEN, HUMMUS, FETA, ROASTED RED PEPPER, OLIVES, SPINACH, RED ONION

  US$10.99

• THE BUFF CHICK

  CRISPY CHICKEN, BUFFALO, RANCH, PEPPER JACK, LETTUCE, TOMATO, BANANA PEPPERS ON A CIABATTA PANINI

  US$11.99

• THE ALIBI

  FRIED CHICKEN, COLE SLAW, FRIED PICKLES, SPICY MAYO, ON A ROLL

  US$11.99

• EGGPLANT

  CRISPY EGGPLANT, FRESH MOZZARELLA, ARUGULA, TOMATO, BALSAMIC GLAZE, GARLIC AIOLI ON A CIABATTA PANINI

  US$11.99

• CREATE YOUR OWN SANDWICH

  BASE PRICE

  US$7.99

BUT WAIT THERE'S MORE!

• FRIES / TATER TOTS / SWEET POTATO FRIES

  US$4.99

• TRUFFLE PARMESAN FRIES

  US$5.99

• JALAPENO POPPER

  CREAM CHEESE, CHEDDAR, MONTEREY JACK AND JALAPENO

• SPINACH ARTICHOKE

  A BLEND OF 5 CHEESES, SPINACH AND ARTICHOKE HEARTS

• FIG HONEY GOAT CHEESE

  DRIED FIGS, CREAMY GOAT CHEESE AND HONEY

Others

• BANANA NUTELLA

  BANANAS AND NUTELLA

• APPLE CRUMB EXPLOSION

  APPLE PIE, WHITE CHOCOLATE CHIPS, CARAMEL AND CRUMBS

• BROWNIE MADNESS

  BROWNIE BATTER, WHITE AND MILK CHOCOLATE CHIPS, OREOS

• BROCCOLI SALAD

  CHOPPED BROCCOLI, SUNFLOWER SEEDS, DRIED CRANBERRIES, CREAMY VINAIGRETTE

  US$5.99

• CRISPY WONTONS BAKED OR FRIED

  6/$12 OR 12/$22 OR FROZEN BY THE DOZEN $14

• PHILLY CHEESESTEAK

  BEEF, CHEDDAR, PARMESAN, ONION SEASONING

• CHEESEBURGER

  GROUND BEEF, AMERICAN CHEESE & A HINT OF PICKLES AND KETCHUP

• HONEY BBQ CHICKEN

  WHITE MEAT CHICKEN AND HONEY BBQ SAUCE

• BACON MAC & CHEESE

  A BLEND OF 4 CHEESES, PASTA AND BACON PIECES

• BUFFALO CHICKEN

  WHITE MEAT CHICKEN, BUFFALO SAUCE AND A HINT OF BLUE CHEESE DRESSING