The Hidden Gem Cafe (now The Stuffed American)

Welcome to The Stuffed American, a delightful cafe tucked away in the lower level of 275 Broadhollow Rd in Melville, NY. Formerly known as The Hidden Gem Cafe, this charming eatery lives up to its new name with an enticing menu that promises to satisfy your cravings while offering an inviting atmosphere for all who step through its doors.

From the moment you enter, you’ll be greeted by cheerful staff and a cozy vibe that makes it the perfect spot for a quick bite or a leisurely lunch. The cafe specializes in fresh, flavorful options across a variety of categories including salads, sandwiches, wraps, and delectable desserts. Each dish is crafted with quality ingredients, ensuring a memorable dining experience.

Start your meal with one of their fresh salads. The Italian Salad combines fresh spinach, mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, olives, and a touch of tangy balsamic glaze – a true testament to Italy's flavors at just $8.99. For those looking for something heartier, the Cobb Salad, packed with grilled chicken, romaine, avocado, and Gorgonzola, is a fulfilling choice at $12.99.

When it comes to sandwiches, you can't go wrong with the Truffle Shuffle. This crispy chicken masterpiece features rich truffle burrata, fresh arugula, roasted peppers, and a pleasing balsamic glaze – all bundled together on a roll for just $11.99. And for the adventurous palate, the Hidden Parmwich comes highly recommended, showcasing the cafe’s creativity and dedication to flavor.

Sweeten your experience with one of their indulgent desserts. The Banana Nutella is a heavenly combination of ripe bananas and luscious Nutella, while the Apple Crumb Explosion features apple pie goodness topped with white chocolate chips and caramel – both are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth! Don’t forget to grab one of the cafe's famous massive cookies, as they are a crowd favorite and make for a perfect companion to your coffee.

With rave reviews from customers, it's clear that The Stuffed American has gained a devoted following. Judith Marando reminisces about how the cafe catered her wedding and now provides food for her daughter’s birthday parties, showcasing the café's reliability and commitment to quality. Brice, a visitor who walked over from the Marriott, admired the great food and friendly staff, highlighting the welcoming atmosphere that keeps his spirits high even on the busiest days.

Angela Scolaro praised the cafe’s delightful catering, mentioning that their grazing table was a work of art and left her guests raving about the freshness and flavor of the food. This feedback represents the true essence of what The Stuffed American aims for: warmth, quality, and a personal touch that makes every dish memorable.

In a world of crowded cafes, this hidden gem in Melville shines brightly, enticing locals and visitors alike to indulge in its exceptional offerings. With its friendly environment, creative and wholesome menu, and standout customer service, The Stuffed American is undoubtedly a must-visit destination for food lovers in the area.